Okay so I decided to take on the Moonlight dagger quest and I got all the items Alem desires which he said the following- 1 cutter 4 slot, 1 oridecon anvil, 25 steel, 5 nine tail, 35 fabric, and 100k. I obtained all these in excess and I go to get my reward and no dice, he says that I don't have all the required items. So am I missing one he didnt list or is something wrong. Atm I have for the quest:
2 cutter[4]s*1 of them +8 the other just non upgraded*,27 steel, 35 fabric, 9 nine tails and 260k and the ordecon anvil of course.

hes right, the npc is bugged or something. tested on my GM. i exchanged his items for the dagger.

You could have asked me ingame I woulda given it to you for free. A lot of people have extra junk so what I recommend it starting a chatroom saying need> (item goes here) and im sure someone would have one and you could discuss something.